Dr. Sarah Foster on reconciling fisheries and conservation at #COFI37
We live in a world that urgently needs to reconcile fisheries and conservation. That is why it mattered for our program leader, Dr. Sarah Foster, to be in Rome for the 37th Session of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) Committee on Fisheries (COFI). Here, Sarah shares her reflections and key takeaways from the meeting.
COFI is, in FAO’s own words, “the only global inter-governmental forum where FAO Members meet to consider the issues related to fisheries and aquaculture” – a mandate no other body holds.
I attended COFI as part of the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) delegation, as a member of the Species Survival Commission, and sat alongside colleagues from the IUCN Commission on Ecosystem Management’s Fisheries Expert Group. My goal was simple: to listen and learn. I wanted to better understand how the fisheries world talks about the issues our team at Project Seahorse works on every day, and where conservation and fisheries already work well together, and where they still don’t speak the same language.
Here are four takeaways from the meeting:
1. We need to remember coastal fisheries and ecosystems
The meeting opened with FAO’s latest State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture (SOFIA), which reported that aquaculture production has now overtaken wild capture for the first time. Many Member interventions on this item stressed aquaculture’s importance for feeding a growing world, and a dedicated aquaculture agenda item followed shortly after. Then, later in the week, discussions of FAO’s role in supporting international agreements leaned heavily toward the high seas, known formally as areas beyond national jurisdiction, and the new Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) Agreement governing them.
I understand the reasons for these discussions, but it left me feeling uneasy. It felt as though the room had moved on from coastal fisheries and ecosystems – when there is still so much work to do. Most fishing happens within national waters. These waters provide food and livelihoods for millions of people, and are home to the vast majority of marine biodiversity. We cannot let our attention and resources drift away from them.
2. Let’s remember the UU in IUU
Illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing also featured on the agenda. Most of the discussion centred on the illegal element, and understandably so: the Agreement on Port State Measures and transparency tools such as Global Fishing Watch’s public vessel tracking have driven real progress there.
I was left wondering how the room plans to tackle the other two-thirds of the acronym – unreported and unregulated.
We know that a lot of catch is not managed in any meaningful way, especially in highly nonselective fisheries like bottom trawling. And we know that catch is still poorly documented for many small-scale and data-poor fisheries. Illegal fishing has strong momentum behind it. Unreported and unregulated fishing needs the same.
3. A new term for me: “biodiversity mainstreaming”
The idea is fairly simple – protecting biodiversity should be built into the policies and decisions of sectors like fisheries and aquaculture, rather than treating conservation as an objective to be handled elsewhere.
COFI’s 2026-2027 workplan includes it as a new area of emphasis: “strengthened biodiversity mainstreaming in fisheries to conserve target species and the broader environment.” But it isn’t clear how this will happen. Unlike other goals, this one names no instrument, tool or measure of success, so for now it reads as an aspiration rather than a plan of action.
IUCN raised a related gap. In our statement on how FAO supports international agreements, we pointed out that the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework – the agreement that mainstreaming is meant to help deliver – gets only a passing mention in the Committee’s paper. Nothing explains how FAO will help fisheries and the Framework work together. We urged FAO to engage more closely with the Framework, and made a similar case for the BBNJ Agreement and the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), so that their implementation draws on fisheries science and management rather than developing in parallel.
4. There is still a lot of work to reconcile fisheries and conservation
As someone who works foremost in the conservation space, attending COFI37 was itself an attempt to close that gap. And it is a gap worth naming clearly: this isn’t only an international body problem. It is a national one, and an organizational one too.
The same countries take part in fisheries and biodiversity discussions, and often the same NGOs do too – but frequently different people attend each, and they don’t always coordinate. Take CITES. Countries vote on trade rules for aquatic species, yet fisheries authorities do not always agree with how their own country votes. That is an internal coordination challenge, not a flaw in FAO or CITES.
Genuine collaboration is needed at every level – internationally, regionally and nationally. Not tokenism, but a real willingness to listen, learn and problem-solve from all sides.
At Project Seahorse, we will keep working as an honest broker to help close this gap. After all, healthy fisheries depend on healthy oceans, and healthy oceans depend, in turn, on better fisheries.


